Employee Rights in the Wild West

Lewis Hall

Lewis Hall


24 Oct 2018


Rockstar Games recently made headlines, not because of its long-awaited new release Red Dead Redemption 2 however, but because of allegations of a Wild West atmosphere in their workplace.

Some of the reports coming from the studio are particularly animated, and claim employees are working 100+ hour weeks, expected to perform overtime as standard (including weekends), and that there is a culture of fear when pushing out a new game. Other reports claim that the studio is a fantastic place to work, and overtime is available, as is work over the weekends, but isn’t mandatory. With such conflicting reports it is hard to pin down the reality of the situation, but one thing Rockstar have done is encourage employee feedback to try and get a proper grasp on the current atmosphere.

US and UK working legislation differ in many respects, which raises the question: can these issues be found in UK workplaces, or are they restricted to those working on the frontier?

The working week

UK legislation dictates that adult employees cannot work more than 48 hours a week on average over a 17-week reference period, unless they opt out of the 48-hour week. There are some exceptions to this rule, such as:

  • A workplace that requires 24-hour staffing, i.e. a care home
  • Armed forces & emergency services
  • Security and surveillance roles
  • Working at sea
  • If you are self-employed and have control over your own hours
  • An agreement with your workforce extending the reference period, up to 52 weeks
  • Young workers who legally can’t work more than 8 hours a day or 40 hours a week.

If you force an employee to work more than 48 hours a week, you are breaking the law, and a case can be made against you at an employment tribunal. Similarly, if you pressure an employee into working more hours than they are contracted to perform, as appears to be the case for Rockstar games, an employee could hand in their notice and claim constructive dismissal.

Culture of fear

Some employees of Rockstar claimed there was a culture of fear during what they called ‘Crunch Time’, referring to the period building up to the release of a new game.

Fear-based tactics can drive results like no other method, but the effect it has on the workforce can be devastating, and it could ultimately land you in very hot water. Fear is a short-term motivator, but a long-term drain on morale. Employees can become resentful of leadership, and their work can suffer as a result, or they could simply choose to find employment elsewhere.

Don’t believe us? A recent Croner Twitter Survey found that work environment was the most common reason employees quit their current job.

What can be done?

Sometimes it isn’t clear if your workplace is run by fear or not, so here are a few signs that you can look out for:

  • Do you or your team-leaders micromanage?
  • Does communication get passed down the chain of command, but not back up, or across departments?
  • Are employees more focused on their daily goals than their long-term targets?
  • Are employees (and leaders) ranking individuals against one another?
  • Is your staff turnover rate high? Also, when an employee leaves, do their colleagues speak about them?

If the answer to any of these questions is ‘yes’, it may be worth communicating with employees and trying to establish where things are going wrong. In a healthy workplace trust is key, leaders must learn to delegate properly (not overloading employees), coach their teams and encourage communication without filters. This is one thing Rockstar have done in light of the allegations against them, showing they are ready to listen to the criticism they have received.

In terms of legality, a court case at the beginning of the year ruled in favour of an employee who worked in a culture of fear, despite the fact she fabricated details on work-related documentation. This shows that a culture of fear, while not necessarily direct bullying or harassment (which is deemed unlawful under the Equality Act 2010) can still lead to a successful tribunal claim being made.

Expert Support

If you have concerns with any of the topics raised in this article, or have a HR issue you need expert advice on, speak to one of Croner’s consultants on 0808 145 3382


About the Author

Lewis Hall

Lewis Hall is Croner's Marketing Executive, responsible for producing, sourcing, and organising content across the website. He has a background of working in the legal marketing industry and is also responsible for Croner's social media channels, so keep your eyes peeled for fresh content!


Lewis Hall

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Pay Awards & Forecast (September 2018)


    Pay Awards & Forecast (September 2018...

    Read Croner Reward's expert settlement and forecast report for September 2018

    Read more
  • Sample Health & Safety Policy Statement


    Sample Health & Safety Policy Stateme...

    Here we’ve included a free sample Health & Safety Policy Statement that UK business owners can refer to.

    Read more
  • Pay Awards & Forecast (June 2018)


    Pay Awards & Forecast (June 2018)

    Read Croner Reward's expert Settlements and Forecasts report for June 2018

    Read more
  • How Much Does Employee Turnover Cost Your Business?


    How Much Does Employee Turnover Cost ...

    A recent Glassdoor survey revealed that almost 35% of hiring professionals expec...

    Read more
  • Staff Turnover: What Do You Need to Know?


    Staff Turnover: What Do You Need to K...

    Having a high worker turnover can have mean two things: A negative impact on you...

    Read more
  • What is Wrongful Dismissal?


    What is Wrongful Dismissal?

    If you breach an employee’s contract, you could be liable for wrongful dismissal...

    Read more
  • bemrose-school-derby


    Bemrose School Derby

    “Having Croner-i saves us a lot of time and money, as we do not have to use cred

    Read more
  • wmtr



    “I’d definitely recommend the Croner OnSite services and I have done already, I

    Read more
  • certikin



    “Our Distribution Manager had a particularly technical query relating to respira

    Read more

Ready to focus on what you do best?

Get your free consultation and speak to an expert today.