Hermes Legal Action - What This Means for the Gig Economy

blog-publish-date

03 May 2018

blog-read-duration

The latest legal chapter concerning workers’ rights in the so called gig economy has begun, with eight delivery drivers taking action against their employer Hermes.

The workers’ status case is around how Hermes categorises their drivers as self-employed, which means they are not entitled to employment rights such as minimum wage, paid holiday or minimum rest breaks. The drivers have commenced employment tribunal proceedings claiming they are actually workers who should receive worker rights. The claim against Hermes follows a number of high profile cases against other employers within the so-called ‘gig economy’, including Uber and Deliveroo. In 2016 the ride-hailing firm Uber was told its drivers should be classed as “workers” with minimum-wage rights. Uber, which says its drivers are self-employed, lost its appeal against the decision last year but said it would appeal again. The case could end up in the Supreme Court this year. The Hermes claim mirrors several other similar tribunal hearings – including verdicts in cases brought against Uber, Addison Lee, City Sprint, Excel and eCourier – where judges have ruled that their staff should be given the legal classification as “workers”, thereby receiving the minimum wage and holiday pay rights.

Expert Opinion

Whilst the majority of these cases have resulted in a finding that the claimant was a worker, there is no guarantee that a similar finding will be made against Hermes. Instead, the employment tribunal will review all the facts of the case including any documentation, whether the delivery driver is subject to control, and whether there is a right to substitute another person to carry out the work. Importantly, the tribunal will look beyond any documents or labels given to the individual to examine how the relationship actually works in reality. If they find, in reality, the individual is treated as if they were a worker then they will go on to find the correct status is that of a worker. A decision which finds Hermes have categorised their workforce incorrectly could lead to a substantial financial claim as they will have to reimburse any shortfall in wages or holiday pay, as well as go on to provide these in the future.

Expert Support

The Government has confirmed that businesses operating in the so called ‘gig economy’ will be required to pay their workers sick and holiday pay as part of the Taylor Review into Modern Working Practices. Full details will be made public in the forthcoming ‘Good Work’ plan by the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy. With more and more firms adopting working practices affected by the Taylor Review it’s essential for employers to ascertain the employment status of your workforce and ensure that they are receiving the correct entitlements. Download our free employment status factsheet here for guidance, or call an employment law expert today on 0808 145 3490.

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Model Apprenticeship Agreement

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Model Apprenticeship Agreement

    Read more
  • Sample COSHH Assessment Record

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Sample COSHH Assessment Record

    Read more
  • Return to Work Interview Form

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Return to Work Interview Form

    Read more
  • Eye Health in the Workplace

    BLOG

    Eye Health in the Workplace

    On average 1000 injuries occur to people’s eyes every day.[1] The best way to p...

    Read more
  • Case Law - Discrimination Outside of Work

    BLOG

    Case Law - Discrimination Outside of ...

    The EAT has held that employers could avoid being liable for discriminatory acts...

    Read more
  • Fire Safety in the Workplace

    BLOG

    Fire Safety in the Workplace

      If you’re reading this, and you’re an employer, you—yes you—are responsible...

    Read more
  • Syalons

    CASE STUDY

    Syalons

    International Syalons is a manufacturer of advanced ceramics, working for variou...

    Read more
  • Pangea Support

    CASE STUDY

    Pangea Support

    We see Croner being integral to our organisation moving forward, and we’d defini

    Read more
  • JC Couriers

    CASE STUDY

    JC Couriers

    With Croner it genuinely feels like they want me to be a success. And I'm happy

    Read more

Do you have any questions?

Get a free callback from one of our regional experts today