Holiday Pay and Overtime

blog-publish-date

05 Sep 2017

blog-read-duration

The latest chapter of the never-ending story of what to pay a worker when they are on a period of annual leave has been written, and the Employment Appeal tribunal (EAT) has been clear in concluding that voluntary over time should be included (in some circumstances) in the calculation of “normal remuneration”, and therefore ought to be paid when that individual takes annual leave (or at least for the first 4 weeks of leave, so as to reflect the entitlement that is provided for by the Working Time Directive (WTD)). Dudley Metropolitan Borough Council v Willetts and others, is the first binding decision in England and Wales on the issue of voluntary overtime. This case considered employees who were employed across various roles but who all had set hours dictated. In addition to those hours, they were able to dip in and out of a rota which gave them the opportunity to earn extra through on-call supplements and additional overtime, all of which was considered voluntary since they were free to choose whether to take on work to suit themselves. The Employment Tribunal decision, in the first instance, has been upheld by the EAT and their decision stipulates that for pay to be considered as “normal remuneration”, and therefore included when calculating holiday pay, it must have been paid over a sufficient period of time, be paid regularly, or be paid on a reoccurring basis. This sets an important precedent on the issue of what overtime should be considered when calculating holiday pay, but employers should still consider their position on a case by case basis giving considerations to appropriate factors affecting their workers and work structures. Previous case law which considered this issue has identified that the calculation of payment during periods of annual leave should take into account contractual requirements which are ‘intrinsically linked to the performance of the required tasks’ but that did not take account of ‘occasional or ancillary costs’. There has been some debate over whether voluntary overtime needed to be considered for the purposes of holiday pay calculations, with many employers viewing it as a chink of light to possibly avoid incurring further costs when it comes to workers taking leave. Unfortunately, this EAT decision has blacked out that light and moving forward normal remuneration will only disregard payments which are exceptional or not usually paid. Fundamentally the Tribunals have identified that narrow interpretation of “normal remuneration” only serves to put workers at a financial disadvantage and as such deters them from taking holiday. To that end, if there is payment made over a sufficient period of time, on a regular basis, say for one week each month or one week in every five weeks, even if it is not paid more frequently or even each week, then it ought to be factored in.  

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Pay Awards & Forecast (September 2018)

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Pay Awards & Forecast (September 2018...

    Read Croner Reward's expert settlement and forecast report for September 2018

    Read more
  • Sample Health & Safety Policy Statement

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Sample Health & Safety Policy Stateme...

    Here we’ve included a free sample Health & Safety Policy Statement that UK business owners can refer to.

    Read more
  • Pay Awards & Forecast (June 2018)

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Pay Awards & Forecast (June 2018)

    Read Croner Reward's expert Settlements and Forecasts report for June 2018

    Read more
  • How Much Does Employee Turnover Cost Your Business?

    BLOG

    How Much Does Employee Turnover Cost ...

    A recent Glassdoor survey revealed that almost 35% of hiring professionals expec...

    Read more
  • Staff Turnover: What Do You Need to Know?

    BLOG

    Staff Turnover: What Do You Need to K...

    Having a high worker turnover can have mean two things: A negative impact on you...

    Read more
  • What is Wrongful Dismissal?

    BLOG

    What is Wrongful Dismissal?

    If you breach an employee’s contract, you could be liable for wrongful dismissal...

    Read more
  • bemrose-school-derby

    CASE STUDY

    Bemrose School Derby

    “Having Croner-i saves us a lot of time and money, as we do not have to use cred

    Read more
  • wmtr

    CASE STUDY

    WMTR

    “I’d definitely recommend the Croner OnSite services and I have done already, I

    Read more
  • certikin

    CASE STUDY

    Certikin

    “Our Distribution Manager had a particularly technical query relating to respira

    Read more

Ready to focus on what you do best?

Get your free consultation and speak to an expert today.