No more nominal payments as consideration?

blog-publish-date

14 Jun 2016

blog-read-duration

The law of contract provides that whenever a change is made to a contract of employment the variation will only be valid if something of value (known as “consideration”) passes from each party to the other. As a result, one often sees a nominal payment (typically of £100 or so) being made in return for the employee agreeing to new post-termination restrictions. However, the recent case of Pickwell & Nicholls v Pro Cam CP Ltd suggests that, in the future, such variations may be upheld even in the absence of such a payment. The case concerned two trainee employees who started work without written contracts. When written contracts were presented for signature, some months after each employee commenced employment, they included restrictions on the employees’ ability to deal with Pro Cam’s customers following the termination of their employment. On the subsequent termination of their employment, Pickwell and Nicholls argued that the restrictions were not valid, in part because their introduction had not been supported by consideration. However, the Court found that if the Claimants had not agreed to the restrictions they would have been denied access to clients/confidential information and might even have been dismissed. On this basis, there was consideration – the thing of value passing to the employees was that access and their continuing employment. Andrew Willis, manager of Croner’s Litigation & Commercial Legal teams, explains: “Our clients understandably want to do as much as they can to protect their legitimate business interests. We therefore provide them with standard contracts – including restrictions and obligations to protect their client relationships, employees and products where appropriate – which help them to do this. “This case is helpful in that, where old contracts need to be varied to provide such protection, it suggests an additional means by which the variation may be upheld. However, we would always recommend that clients take advice when making such changes and include an express statement that the employee is being given access to clients and information – and perhaps being retained as an employee – on the basis of, and as consideration for, the contractual variation being agreed to and signed. “With regard to any contractual amendment; switching to a secure, online system can be beneficial, as it enables the employer to electronically distribute documentation to its employees, no matter where they are based, and monitor who has read/agreed to the changes. It also makes it easier to store and find the latest versions.” For more information on how Croner can help with contracts and handbooks, please call 0800 032 4088.

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Grievance Policy Guide & Template

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Grievance Policy Guide & Template

    Read more
  • Sickness Absence Policy & Procedure

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Sickness Absence Policy & Procedure

    Read more
  • Bribery Risk Assessment Form

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Bribery Risk Assessment Form

    Read more
  • BLOG

    Parental Bereavement Leave Becomes La...

    In 2010, Lucy Herd lost her son Jack. She was shocked to find how little time he...

    Read more
  • BLOG

    Case Law Update - Discrimination Canc...

    The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) has ruled that individuals who have been di...

    Read more
  • BLOG

    EHRC Release anti-harassment guidance

    New guidance has been released for employers on preventing harassment at work. T...

    Read more
  • Print Inc.

    CASE STUDY

    Print Inc.

    Print Inc. are an embroidery and print company based in Carmarthenshire, South W...

    Read more
  • Scotgold Resources

    CASE STUDY

    Scotgold Resources

    A lot of organisations believe they’re sitting on a gold mine. Scotgold resource

    Read more
  • Wacoal

    CASE STUDY

    Wacoal

    “Overall, we’re very happy with the service Croner provides and we’d recommend i

    Read more

Do you have any questions?

Get a free callback from one of our regional experts today