Ban on the Wearing of Political, Philosophical or Religious Signs at Work may be Lawful

blog-publish-date

17 Mar 2017

blog-read-duration

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that companies may ban “the visible wearing of any political, philosophical or religious sign" in the workplace. This need not constitute direct discrimination, as long as the rule is applied to all members of staff equally and does not single out particular groups. Such a ban may affect Muslim staff who wear headscarves at work – if it was only applied to that group of employees it would almost certainly constitute unlawful discrimination. The ban must be based on internal company rules requiring all employees to "dress neutrally", said the Court. As a result such a policy might equally affect employees who wear other religious insignia such as crucifixes, skullcaps and turbans. In addition such a ban cannot simply be based on the wishes of a customer.

Advice to Employers

Andrew Willis, Croner’s Head of Litigation, comments: “The ruling has been met with a range of reactions, with some predicting that it will give greater leeway for employers to discriminate against staff on the ground of their religion. “In fact, such policies will only be lawful if they do not discriminate on the ground of a particular religious or philosophical belief. “It is also important to remember an employer’s duty not to indirectly discriminate – by placing people who adhere to a particular religion or belief at a particular disadvantage without justification. “As an example, wearing certain forms of dress might be ruled out by safety concerns. This would be lawful provided it was objectively justified as an appropriate and necessary way of achieving a legitimate aim – and consideration would need to be given to offering any affected employee a different position. ”

Background

The ruling arose from a case involving a receptionist fired for wearing a headscarf to her workplace in Belgium. Ms Samira Achbita was fired in June 2006 when, after three years of employment, she began wearing a headscarf to work. At the time of Ms Achbita's hiring, an "unwritten rule" had been in operation banning overt religious symbols, and the company subsequently went on to include this explicitly in its workplace regulations.

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Sample Mental Health Policy

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Sample Mental Health Policy

    Read more
  • Disciplinary Letter Template

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Disciplinary Letter Template

    Read more
  • H&S Risks of Sleep in Shifts

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    H&S Risks of Sleep in Shifts

    Read more
  • What is Unconscious Bias?

    BLOG

    What is Unconscious Bias?

    This issue is prevalent in a number of workplaces across the UK and is a difficu...

    Read more
  • What are Protected Characteristics?

    BLOG

    What are Protected Characteristics?

    There have been various legislations in the UK protecting individuals from discr...

    Read more
  • Cricket World Cup: Dealing with Sporting Events in the Workplace

    BLOG

    Cricket World Cup: Dealing with Sport...

    The 2019 Cricket World Cup will run from 30th May through to 14th July. Matches ...

    Read more
  • Numark

    CASE STUDY

    Numark

    Numark serve as a virtual head office for independent pharmacies on the high str...

    Read more
  • Gilmour Quinn

    CASE STUDY

    Gilmour Quinn

    Gilmour Quinn Financial Planning Ltd is, as the name suggests, a small financial...

    Read more
  • Wardman Brown

    CASE STUDY

    Wardman Brown

    "I would say it has has a noticeable impact, in particular it has improved the H

    Read more

Ready to focus on what you do best?

Get your free consultation and speak to an expert today.