25 Sep 2020
Ideally, your workforce should be harmonious and easy to manage. However, even the best workplaces encounter staff issues. The key question is when does employee behaviour become insubordination?
What does insubordination mean?
In business terms, it’s when a staff member actively disobeys the order of a superior.
However, this is somewhat vague. For example, what if an employee refuses to obey a request, rather than an order? Or, what if they frequently display insolent behaviour? When does that become insubordination?
Some cases are straightforward, but others are difficult to determine. So, when considering, insubordination we need to look into specific examples of behaviour.
In particular, we should determine what behaviour is insubordinate and what classifies as misconduct.
What is insubordination at work?
Serious insubordination examples at work include:
- Openly mocking the business or management decisions.
- Actively ignoring orders from a superior and line manager or refusing to complete tasks.
- Showing disrespect to management with rude, aggressive, or threatening behaviour.
- Expressing dissatisfaction through non-verbal means.
The difficulty of spotting insubordination at work in the UK is knowing the difference between free dialogue and insolent behaviour. If an employee challenges your ideas or offers a different opinion, this is not defiance.
If, however, your employee is consistently challenging you and is doing so in a rude or mocking way, you could consider that insubordination.
What to do about insubordination at work
Dealing with stubborn or defiant employees can mean pursuing a disciplinary procedure.
However, you can try to handle the issue informally first. Having difficult conversations is part of managing people, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy. Here’s how to approach it:
- Stay professional at all times. If they’re rude or loud, don’t meet their level. Always address the employee politely.
- Clearly outline their behaviour is unacceptable. Tell them you’re speaking to them because you believe they’re being insubordinate. Outline the disciplinary actions and consequences of such behaviour if they continue acting this way.
- Hear them out. Even if you’re frustrated, they may have a genuine grievance you need to address.
- Refer to your policies. You should have clear guidelines on conduct in your handbook. Remind the employee of these and your intention to act on them if their behaviour continues.
Sometimes employee behaviour crosses the line and you may have to consider dismissal. Let’s take a step back and define what is considered insubordination in the workplace and what is gross misconduct.
What counts as gross insubordination?
Some acts of disrespect may not constitute serious insubordination. In these cases, it’s important to act early to stop the issue escalating.
However, some rudeness or aggression may immediately cross the line. Then you may need to go straight to a disciplinary. When this happens, it’s important you know exactly where that line is.
To do this we need to ask the question, “What is serious insubordination?” Unfortunately, there’s no clear answer to this. The best way for you to answer this question is to use your employee handbook. Outline what you consider serious insubordination, including examples, in your handbook.
List threatening or aggressive behaviours that aren’t acceptable. This way, you can refer back to the handbook when dealing with employee insubordination.
Insubordination and gross misconduct
There’s no strict legal definition of gross misconduct in the UK. But the government defines gross misconduct as:
“Theft, physical violence, gross negligence, or serious insubordination.”
That means you can consider “serious insubordination” as gross misconduct. Again, you should set out what you consider this to be within your documentation. If necessary, you may suspend the employee while carrying out an investigation.
Where the case is extremely severe, it may be necessary to summarily dismiss the employee.
However, you may only do this if their contract says so. Make sure you check for this clause before dismissing them. Failure to do so will probably result in a claim of unfair dismissal.
If an employer is to dismiss the employee, they must ensure they do so with a written warning and provide notice.
If you’re struggling on how to deal with insubordination or an insubordinate employee, speak to a Croner expert today for quick, impartial advice. We’re experts in employer and employee relations, with experienced employment law advisors. Call today on 01455 858 132.
Do you have any questions?
Get a free callback from one of our regional experts today