Ruling States no NMW for Workers Who ‘Sleep-in’ During Night Shifts

blog-publish-date

17 Jul 2018

blog-read-duration

Employers in the care sector recently learned that workers are not entitled to the National Minimum Wage during a ‘sleep in’ shift unless they are actually working. The ruling marks a dramatic turnaround as the judge declared that all previous cases addressing the issue had come to the wrong decision. Now, employers will not need to make ‘extra payments’ to their employees who are ‘available for work’ while sleeping rather than actually working through a night shift.

Previous cases put employers in an extremely difficult financial situation, they ruled that NMW was payable for every hour of a sleep in shift, regardless of whether they were working or not. This meant employer’s faced the reality of increasing employees’ pay to ensure NMW was correctly paid, a particularly pertinent issue considering the number of employers recently named and shamed. It also threatened employers with a significant back pay that could have stretched back up to 6 years. This potential for back pay liability has now been quashed. Andy Willis, head of legal & advisory at Croner, states: “The decision the Court came to was based on the National Minimum Wage Regulation 1999, that states there are two different types of time work: one where the worker is actively working, and one where the worker is merely available for work. Where the worker is available for work, the only hours that count are those when the worker is awake for the purposes of working, even if the worker, by arrangement, sleeps at work and has been provided with suitable facilities for sleeping.” If a worker sleeps at or near work for the purpose of performing tasks if called upon, they are now only entitled to receive NMW for when they are actually called to work. Hours spent asleep will not require NMW payments, according to the Court. There is still the possibility that the employee involved in this case will hit back against the decision, which may mean another reversal in the Court’s decision. This decision does not change workers right to the NMW if they are actually working a night shift. For example, a recent case with a night watchman found that by the nature of being at the workplace, the worker was in fact working. The case also opens up questions surrounding the National Minimum Wage, leaving the Government in a somewhat awkward position. The original guidance has already been adjusted once to fit case law judgements, but it is very possible that this position could be changed again to reflect the latest Court of Appeal’s decision.

Expert Support

If you have a query regarding the National Minimum Wage, or are experiencing a HR issue, speak to an expert 0808 145 3003

Free to Download Employer Resources

  • Letter Informing Employee they are to be Dismissed for Gross Misconduct

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Letter Informing Employee they are to...

    Read more
  • Letter Informing Employee they are to be Laid Off

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Letter Informing Employee they are to...

    Read more
  • Social Media Policy Template

    FREE DOWNLOAD

    Social Media Policy Template

    Read more
  • Construction Regulations: Guide for Employers

    BLOG

    Construction Regulations: Guide for E...

    The Construction (Design and Management) Regulations 2015 affect you no matter w...

    Read more
  • Drug Testing in the Workplace

    BLOG

    Drug Testing in the Workplace

    The 2017/18 Crime Survey for England and Wales found that one-third of adults ag...

    Read more
  • What is a Competitive Salary?

    BLOG

    What is a Competitive Salary?

    There’re a number of factors that determine an employee’s appointment to your or...

    Read more
  • Numark

    CASE STUDY

    Numark

    Numark serve as a virtual head office for independent pharmacies on the high str...

    Read more
  • Gilmour Quinn

    CASE STUDY

    Gilmour Quinn

    Gilmour Quinn Financial Planning Ltd is, as the name suggests, a small financial...

    Read more
  • Wardman Brown

    CASE STUDY

    Wardman Brown

    "I would say it has has a noticeable impact, in particular it has improved the H

    Read more

Ready to focus on what you do best?

Get your free consultation and speak to an expert today.